This idea came from my late grandfather (Poppy) who was an avid coin collector. Poppy had a very large coin collection, and he was always fascinated with pennies. My mom was a waitress, and she always saved her change for the whole year, and that ended up being her Christmas gift money. I remember when ever Poppy would visit, we would sit down at a table, and dump out all of my mom’s change. We would look at every coin individually and determine if it had a value. I never really new anything about coins, but I did have a small collection because of him. He had one trick that I thought was clever. He was always looking for wheat pennies, but he never waited around to find them. He would go to the bank, hand them $20, and ask for 40 rolls of pennies.
This got me thinking. Poppy was a collector of wheat pennies, so there must be more. When I looked it up in the completed listings, I was right. There is a huge penny niche out there on eBay that really has a great sell through rate. It’s important to understand what a wheat penny is. A wheat penny is a US coin that is worth $.01 to the general public, but has has two grains of wheat on the back. To the left is a picture of a wheat penny.
So what is a wheat penny worth on eBay. Well that all depends. They are sold a few different ways. They can be sold in a lot, individually, or in rolls. Since I don’t know much about coins, I like to sell them in a roll. That also can make you more money. For some reason, the roll of pennies sell better since there is an element of surprise. Buyers are also looking for an Indian Head penny, so if you can guarantee that they are mixed in, then you will make even more money.
Here is what I do. You can buy a roll of pennies at the bank for $.50, so I generally buy 20 rolls for $10 (make sure you say that you do NOT want new pennies). When I get home I open all of my rolls and start looking for Wheat and Indian head pennies. Majority of the pennies are not what I’m looking for, so I put them aside. When I am done looking through them, I take my unwanted pennies back to the bank (when I am near one), and exchange them for new rolls. I do this until I have a few rolls worth that are filled with wheat and Indian Head pennies. Here are some completed listings:
I have found the most luck selling these when I mix in Indian Head pennies. As you can see, you can turn your $.50 roll of pennies into $20 or more! You also could make more money selling Indian Head pennies individually, but it takes a lot more time. Remember, that the profit on selling Wheat and Indian Head pennies can very, and the more Indian head pennies you include, the higher the profit!
For more eBay tips and tricks, follow The Ebay Entrepreneur Blog HERE
{ 6 comments }











